Leagues
DEL Daily News
DEL Forum
 
Coach Tools
MyDEL
Search Coaches
Coach Records
Change Requests
Changes
Newbie Help
Help Pages
 
DEL Time: 10:10
 
Request For: Pro and College All Sports
Request Title: Better POY evaluation
Description
The way players of the year are calculated is biased in favor of a couple of positions.
For example:
CEL OPOY - QB 63 of the last 65 seasons
CCEL OPOY - QB the last 65 seasons in a row
CBEL DPOY - PG the last 70 seasons in a row
I guess looking at this, it really only applies to basketball and football. In basketball, it might be that we need some sort of new metric tracked (maybe invisibly) that records defensive effectiveness instead of just tallying steals and blocks?
In football ... maybe just balancing the contributions of different players needs to be revisited? A TB or WR might not have the absolute numbers of a QB, but they are occasionally rewarded with MVP type awards in real life (QB does in fact still dominate, just not unanimously.)

Category: Enhancement
Status: In Work (last updated Dec 30 14:01:01 2019 )
Priority: Long Term

Admin Notes


Submitted Dec 2 12:14:04 2019 by Stephen Thompson
Coaches In Favor of Change: Stephen Thompson, Coach Shers, Adnan Bislimovic, M McCusker
Coaches Opposed to Change: none

Comments
Adnan Bislimovic: Could we have an asap update in basketball please! Only C and PG in POY Race. We need new perimeters here. The same for the Allstars !
M McCusker (May 27 09:25:13 2020 ): Iíve only played the baseball sim for a few seasons but so far there seems to be a pretty strong bias toward starting pitchers.
Stephen Thompson (Jul 4 11:43:08 2020 ): I don't play the baseball sim ... but maybe somebody who does can say whether there is a strong bias for starting pitchers, or if closers occasionally win the Cy Young as they do in real life. UPDATE: For the 72nd time in the last 73 seasons, the CBEL DPOY was a point guard.

Vote or Comment on this request


COVID trends  -  Home  -  Rankings  -  Terms of Service  -  Privacy  -  Downloads  -  Search  -  Contact

Copyright © 1995-2019, Dolphin Simulation Games
All Rights Reserved